Sifting Fact from Fiction: A Critical Thinking Crime Investigation for Secondary RMPS

This activity works brilliantly as a stand-alone lesson or as part of a wider Crime and Justice unit. It focuses on evaluating evidence, balancing aggravating and mitigating factors, and building critical thinking skills.

The Premise

A crime has been committed, but rather than a classic “whodunit,” pupils already know who did it. Instead, they act as an Advisory Jury to work out why it happened and sift fact from fiction. It’s set in the fictional nation of Valoria, giving you total freedom to build on the scenario with custom laws or punishments later without being bound by Scottish legal constraints.

Case Dossier #409

  • The Crime: On Friday, 4th September, 24-year-old Alex Thorne broke into Chen’s Pharmacy. Pharmacist David Chen came out of his office to investigate, a struggle occurred in the dark, and Mr. Chen suffered a fatal injury.
  • The Twist: Alex pleaded guilty immediately upon arrest, so pupils aren’t trying to catch a killer. Instead, they are tasked with establishing motive, intent, and context.
  • The Dilemma: As pupils sift through the evidence (text messages, bank statements, police reports, and local social media feeds), they discover Alex was being blackmailed by a criminal gang threatening violence against a 10-year-old sister over a £5,000 debt.

Skills & Curriculum Links

This makes a great introductory task for sources and the causes of crime, it also serves as an ideal lead-in to discussions around the Aims of Punishment and moral decision-making.

  • Information Handling & Analysis: Pupils cross-reference primary evidence (police reports and text logs) while filtering out red herrings, local gossip, and social media speculation.
  • Evaluation: Pupils explore complex moral themes, including duress versus personal responsibility, intent versus outcome, and the line between premeditated crime and tragic accident.
  • Weighing Aggravating & Mitigating Factors: Pupils learn to balance factors that make a crime worse (loss of life, bringing break-in tools) against details that make it more sympathetic (coercion, clean record, lack of personal greed).

What’s Included in the Resource Pack?

The downloadable pack contains everything you need to run this investigation.

  1. The Official Evidence Pack:
    • Chief Inspector’s Briefing Memo (The pupil instructions)
    • Local Newspaper Report (The Valoria Times)
    • Official Police Crime Scene & Background Report
    • Evidence Screenshots (Text messages and bank statements)
    • Police Interview Excerpt & Social Media Feed
  2. Advisory Jury Case Log: A pupil worksheet to record facts, establish motive, and weigh aggravating and mitigating factors. (Note: If you plan to reuse the laminated evidence packs, make sure to print these logs separately for pupils to write on!)

Classroom Tips & Reflections

  • Keep It Pupil-Led: If your class dynamic allows, don’t explain the story beforehand! Simply place pupils in pairs,hand out one evidence pack and Case Log, and tell them to read Document 1 to start their investigation.
  • Pair Work vs. Groups: I originally tried this in small groups, but having the evidence bound as a booklet made it tricky for 3–4 pupils to share at once. Pairs work much better for keeping everyone actively reading. Some groups will dive straight in, while others might need a quick nudge to get started.
  • Watch Out for Red Herrings: Prompt pupils to compare the official police evidence against the local social media comments. It’s a great way to discuss how easily speculation and false rumours spread in local communities—a very relevant topic right now.
  • Next Steps & Extension: To stretch this into a multi-week unit, you can link it directly to the Aims of Punishment (Protection, Deterrence, Rehabilitation, Retribution) and ask pupils to debate and decide on a fair, suitable sentence for Alex.

Download the Resources

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Scroll to Top